11 of the Best Scary Halloween Dessert Recipes - Holidappy - Celebrations
Updated date:

11 of the Best Scary Halloween Dessert Recipes

Margaret has a passion for cooking, baking, and creating recipes for holidays such as Christmas, Hanukkah, Thanksgiving and Halloween.

Scary, fun and delicious sweet treats to make your Halloween party "spooktacular"

Scary, fun and delicious sweet treats to make your Halloween party "spooktacular"

Make your Halloween event fun, festive, and memorable with these scary desserts! I've found terrific recipes for cute monster cookies, spooky white chocolate ghost pops, spine-chilling zombie cupcakes, ghoulish cake ball brains oozing cherry "blood" and more. They're sure to make the costumed witches, werewolves, vampires, monsters, ghosts and goblins at your party scream with laughter!

11 Great Scary Halloween Desserts

  1. Cake Ball Brains With Oozing Cherry Blood
  2. Chocolate Rats
  3. Zombie Cupcakes
  4. Pumpkin Spider Cupcakes With Dulce de Leche Buttercream and Chocolate Spider Webs
  5. Green Witches' Fingers Cookies
  6. Jello-Filled White Chocolate Eyeballs
  7. "Bones of the Dead" Meringue Cookies
  8. Scary (but Cute) Monster Face Cookies
  9. Monster Whoopie Pies
  10. Oreo Cakester-Style Spiders
  11. Easy White Chocolate Ghost Pops

You'll find information and photos for each below!

Cake Ball Brains Oozing Cherry Blood recipe from HungryHappenings.com

Cake Ball Brains Oozing Cherry Blood recipe from HungryHappenings.com

Cake Ball Brains With Oozing Cherry Blood

If you believe the saying "you are what you eat," gobbling a few of these delightfully disgusting-looking, scrumptious cake ball brains from Beth at Hungry Happenings just might improve your gray matter!

Imagine your guests' surprise when they bite into the white (or gray-tinted) confectionery coating shell of these brain-shaped sweets and discover the bright red, cherry-flavored (faux) blood oozing from the truffle-like chocolate center made from cake moistened with frosting!

You'll need at least one brain-shaped, flexible silicone ice cube mold to make these. The Fred & Friends "Brain Freeze" ice cube mold I recommend has four cavities and the recipe makes between 20 and 36 treats, depending on how thinly you coat the molds with white candy coating. You may want to get two or more of these molds so you can make at least eight cake balls at a time.

Tip: Consider using a prepared boxed chocolate cake mix and canned vanilla frosting and inviting a few friends over to help you make these. It's a fun project that goes much faster when "many hands make light work!"

Halloween chocolate and cream cheese long-tail rat from the Hungry Happenings blog

Halloween chocolate and cream cheese long-tail rat from the Hungry Happenings blog

Eek - a Chocolate Rat!

This cleverly designed chocolate brown long-tail rat, with its pale pink toes, nose, inner ears and tail, is sure to either scare the willies out of your party guests or totally gross them out...which, of course, is what makes it such a fun Halloween dessert. It's actually kind of cute, once you get over the shock of seeing it for the first time!

The body, legs and ears are formed from a delicious chocolate modeling dough made from Oreo cookie crumbs and cream cheese, rolled in more cookie crumbs to resemble fur. Two chocolate chip eyes and pale pink toes, nose, inner ears and tail give this tasty vermin a fairly realistic look at first glance.

Tip: You can make this Longtail Rat recipe from Beth's Hungry Happenings blog up to a week in advance and just bring it back to room temperature before serving. One less thing to worry about on the big day!

Zombie Cupcakes for a Halloween party!

Zombie Cupcakes for a Halloween party!

Zombie Cupcakes

These ghastly, ghoulish zombie-themed sweets from Jamieanne at Sweetest Kitchen are moist chocolate pumpkin cupcakes filled with silky pumpkin buttercream, frosted with chocolate buttercream and dipped in crushed Oreo cookie "dirt." A bloody, green, zombie hand cupcake pick (available at party supply stores and on Amazon) and an Oreo Fudgees cookie "tombstone" are embedded into the top of each one.

Dulce De Leche Pumpkin Cupcakes

Dulce De Leche Pumpkin Cupcakes

Pumpkin Spider Cupcakes With Dulce de Leche Buttercream and Chocolate Spider Webs

There are lots of recipes for October festivities that feature edible spider web decorations, but this one is elevated version with gourmet flavors. Super-moist pumpkin cupcakes are filled with rich, caramel-flavored dulce de leche and frosted with dulce de leche buttercream, so they taste even better than they look! The spider webs are made by piping melted semisweet chocolate in concentric circles and then using the tip of a toothpick to draw radial lines from the center to the edges. Few recipes look as enticing as these decadent spider cupcakes from Sweetest Kitchen.

I think using plastic spider toppers clashes with the sophistication of these gourmet sweets, so I recommend substituting yummy, homemade, edible chocolate spiders. I've made these by placing a mini spider-shaped candy mold on a baking sheet (to stabilize the flexible mold) and filling it with dark chocolate melted in a double boiler over barely simmering water and then tinted with black gel paste food coloring.

I'll share a couple of my tips for making these successfully:

  1. Be sure to use only gel paste or powdered coloring and not liquid, which could make the candy seize up. The only brand I've tried that creates a true, deep black is AmeriColor Super Black gel paste food coloring. (I haven't tried powdered food coloring.)
  2. To make sure the candies come out easily and intact, freeze the filled mold (still on the baking sheet) for about 15 minutes. Place a sheet of baking parchment or freezer paper on your table or kitchen counter. Remove the mold from the freezer and hold it about two inches above the paper, then invert and flex the mold gently to pop out the candies.
Witches Fingers cookies

Witches Fingers cookies

Green Witches' Fingers Cookies

Halloween always brings out lots of different recipes for the always-popular witches' fingers cookies. Sometimes they're called severed finger cookies or ladies' fingers cookies. Whatever you call them, this version is definitely the most delightfully gruesome I've seen!

Green-tinted sugar cookie dough is shaped into gnarled, severed finger shapes complete with wrinkled knuckles. Traditionally, the almond fingernails are painted with red food coloring and attached with a lightly beaten egg white wash. But as you can see in the photo, Sweetest Kitchen's Jamieanne makes them look unnervingly realistic with untinted, blanched almond nails and red gel icing around the edges to create the look of bloody cuticles.

Jamieanne at Sweetest Kitchen used Annie Marshall's Witches' Fingers cookie recipe from her Everyday Annie blog, tinting the dough with green food coloring before giving the cookies her horror-movie-worthy decorating treatment. She served the cookies on a plate atop crushed-Oreo "chocolate dirt."

I prefer to embed them in a shallow baking dish of "dirt pudding" (chocolate pudding topped with crushed Oreo crumbs) so the green fingers protrude at random angles. Definitely eerie!

Jello-Filled White Chocolate Eyeballs

Eyeball-themed recipes abound for All Hallows' Eve, but these sweets add the twist of a red gelatin filling!

These fun and slightly gruesome treats from blogger Elise's MyCupcakeAddiction YouTube channel feature white chocolate shells made in a round silicone cake pop mold. The half-spheres are chilled, filled with prepared and cooled (but not refrigerated) strawberry or raspberry Jello and chilled again to let the gelatin set. Pairs of these are joined with more melted white chocolate. Each candy sphere is decorated with melted green, black and red candy melts for the iris, pupil and squiggly "veins" of the eyeball. Imagine your guests' surprise when they bite into the white chocolate shell and discover the jiggly red filling! Check out the video for the recipe and lots of helpful tips from Elise.

"Bones of the Dead" Meringue Cookies

This easy recipe for bone-shaped meringue cookies from BakeLikeAPro is made from just three ingredients: Egg whites, lemon juice and granulated sugar. It's similar to a traditional Italian treat for the "Day of the Dead" (AKA All Souls' Day or All Saints' Day) known as Ossi dei Morti, which means Bones of the Dead. These crisp meringues are extremely easy to make. And since you need to make them at least a day in advance, you can get them done ahead of time instead of on the day of your Halloween party.

Tip: In most traditional Italian versions, the dough includes finely ground almond or hazelnut flour, sometimes lemon zest and often one or more of the following: ground cinnamon, cloves, anise, black pepper. For a more authentic flavor, consider adding a little almond or hazelnut extract and a pinch of warm spices to this meringue.

Monster Face Cookies

Monster Face Cookies

Scary (but Cute) Monster Face Cookies

Today's Cookie Creature Double Feature: "Dracula vs. Frankenstein's Monster" and "Zombies vs. The Mummy!"

These fabulous Monster Face Cookies look like they might have come from fancy bakery (with an equally fancy price tag) rather than from someone's home kitchen. Yet despite their professional appearance, these kid-friendly, semi-scary cookies are surprisingly easy and fun to make.

They start out as simple sugar cookies, but the brightly colored royal icing and candy decorations turn them into something very special, indeed.

The Decorated Cookie blog's sugar cookie and royal icing recipes are from Meaghan Mountford, who also provides wonderful, easy-to-follow, illustrated step-by-step directions for decorating all four monster face cookies:

  • a vampire cookie with bloody fangs
  • a green fellow who resembles a friendlier version of Frankenstein's monster
  • a mummy whose candy eyes peek out through the bandages
  • a purple zombie with blood dripping from its mouth
Monster Whoopie Pies for Halloween

Monster Whoopie Pies for Halloween

Monster Whoopie Pies

These chocolate monsters from Lizzy at Your Cup of Cake are both silly and scary, so they're perfect for younger guests. The tongue, made by marbleizing red and yellow fruit chew candies, is seriously cool! The white chocolate chip teeth are held in place by luscious chocolate frosting. The googly eyes (marshmallows topped with miniature chocolate-covered mints) make these treats look like something out of the movie Monsters, Inc.

Note: Lizzy uses a devil's food cake mix in this recipe, but I like to make the from scratch using my favorite recipe for chocolate whoopie pies, whose taste I prefer. Your choice!

Oreo Cakester Spiders from The Decorated Cookie blog's guest post on CraftGossip.com

Oreo Cakester Spiders from The Decorated Cookie blog's guest post on CraftGossip.com

Oreo Cakester-Style Spiders

Meaghan Mountford of The Decorated Cookie blog is the former Edible Crafts editor for the fabulous CraftGossip blog. She popped back for a guest post and shared her surprisingly quick and easy 8-eyed, 8-legged, edible black spiders, You can whip up these creepy, crawly, cream-filled spiders in practically no time, and they're easy enough for even young children to make with you!

Since the recipe calls for Oreo Cakesters, which have since been discontinued by Nabisco, I substituted some homemade miniature chocolate whoopie pies, which turned out great. You could also use a round, chocolate-covered, cream-filled snack cake (Hostess Ding Dongs, Drake's Ring Dings or Little Debbie Cocoa Cremes) and use a toothpick to poke holes in the chocolate coating where you want to insert the licorice string "legs."

Follow Meaghan's directions for making Oreo Cakester Spiders on CraftGossip and substitute the individual-sized cream-filled chocolate cake sandwich of your choice!

Easy white chocolate ghost pops

Easy white chocolate ghost pops

Easy White Chocolate Ghost Pops

You Can Almost Hear Them Shout "Boo!"

These white chocolate ghost pops are another spooky sweet treat from The Decorated Cookie. These are extremely easy to make and you can whip up a batch very quickly. All you need are candy melts or white chocolate chips, lollipop sticks and candy eyes. If you have kids or grandchildren, they'll love making these pops with you.

Leave a comment about these scary Halloween dessert recipes ... or I might send my vampire, mummy, zombie or ghoul friends after you!

Margaret Schindel (author) from Massachusetts on September 07, 2020:

Thanks so much for the lovely feedback, Abby! So glad you enjoy these recipes and found some new ones here to try. The brain cake pop truffles really are amazing, aren’t they?

Abby Slutsky from LAFAYETTE HL on September 07, 2020:

These are cute ideas. I have previously made the finger cookies and the merengue bones. The children always love them, and they are great additions to a Halloween cookie tray. Those brain truffles look wonderful. I will have to try them.

poetryman6969 on October 22, 2017:

pretty much proof positive that you had better eat the zombies before they eat you!

Barbara Tremblay Cipak from Toronto, Canada on September 19, 2014:

Margaret! this is awesome, what a page, lmao at the cake brains oozing blood! you know I'm pinning this right? The page looks so good over here as well, very impressive!

Kathryn Grace from San Francisco on September 11, 2014:

The roach popcorn really grossed me out! The spiders on the chocolate chip cookies almost as much, and I'm not at all sure I could bite into the witches' fingers, but those white chocolate ghost pops look scrumptious and I might find myself nibbling more than my share. What a fabulous collection of treats for the Halloween season. Thank you.

Eugene Samuel Monaco from Lakewood New York on August 05, 2014:

Now that's what I call selection!! How very creative, you have given me so many ideas to have fun with my grandchildren. Thanks

SimonJay on December 19, 2013:

The brains, werewolf, the zombie minion, green finger and the graveyard cake all look awesome but think the brains will be the idea ill be using thx.

Lee Hansen from Vermont on November 01, 2013:

Mwaahaaahaaahaaaa nom nom nomn.

AJ from Australia on October 14, 2013:

Oh my - I can't decide which is creepiest - the brains or the witches fingers? So well done and I am so relieved I'm not coming to your party :)

WistfullyWarped on October 12, 2013:

I LOVE this! The roach popcorn is decidedly warped and the Minion - yes! Great inspiration!

Margaret Schindel (author) from Massachusetts on October 04, 2013:

@TreasuresBrenda: Thanks so much, Brenda! I'll take that as a compliment. ;)

RoadMonkey on October 04, 2013:

What a fantastic collection of creative ideas for desserts for hallowe'en!

Corrinna Johnson from BC, Canada on October 04, 2013:

I love all these ideas, especially the roach infested popcorn and edible rat! My kids would go crazy for those. Congratulations on receiving a gift card for your dreadfully awesome article...well deserved!

Pam Irie from Land of Aloha on October 02, 2013:

What a great page with so many cool recipes. Wish I were hosting a Halloween party this year or even going to one. Any of these creepy desserts for Halloween would be welcomed!

Cynthia Sylvestermouse from United States on October 01, 2013:

These are all really awesome suggestions for Halloween! Of course, my favorite is the rat, but they are all really fabulous!

Meganhere on October 01, 2013:

The brains oozing cherry blood, the popcorn infested with roaches, the zombie cupcakes, the witches fingers - love them! Great lens.

Ruthi on September 30, 2013:

The green witch fingers are my favorite, so real looking! And that rat is unbelievably realistic! I'll pass right over anything with spiders, oh my! This is fantastic Halloween food fun and I shall be passing it along to all my fiendish friends!

Margaret Schindel (author) from Massachusetts on September 30, 2013:

@HungryHappenings: Thank YOU, Beth! Your recipes are absolutely awesome.

Happy Halloween to you as well and thanks so much for allowing me to use your fabulous photos in this article!

HungryHappenings on September 30, 2013:

It's so nice to see that so many people like my Cake Ball Brains!! Thanks again for featuring several of my recipes in your lens. I hope you have a Happy Halloween.

AlleyCatLane on September 30, 2013:

Really cute dessert recipes. They would be a real treat at any Halloween party. I especially like the brains.

Margaret Schindel (author) from Massachusetts on September 30, 2013:

@Diana Wenzel: Thanks, Diana! Fortunately chocolate roaches are one infestation you can actually enjoy taking care of... and these little guys don't procreate, ha ha! Enjoy your Halloween treats, my friend.

Margaret Schindel (author) from Massachusetts on September 30, 2013:

@SusanDeppner: Thanks, Susan! I'm so grateful that the three awesome authors and bloggers whose scary Halloween dessert recipes I featured allowed me to share their photos in my article. It makes all the difference, doesn't it?

Renaissance Woman from Colorado on September 30, 2013:

Having lived in Texas with roaches, and having just purchased a new popcorn popper, I'm quite sure I don't want any of those creepy crawlies in my snacks! Yikes. Love the brains and the witches' fingers. So many spooktacular ideas.

anonymous on September 29, 2013:

Oh my gosh! How gross, creepy and fabulous these Halloween dessert recipes are. Great job!

sybil watson on September 29, 2013:

Pinned to my Halloween board on Pinterest - so many great ideas! I agree with Nancy, I'd go for the brains first!

Lorelei Cohen on September 29, 2013:

I like the simple chocolate spider idea. I could use that one on cookies for my grandkids. Love it.

Nancy Carol Brown Hardin from Las Vegas, NV on September 29, 2013:

It's funny, but out of them all, and there are many that are fabulous, I still stick with the cake brains. They just really stand out I think!